what different kind of problem should be considered during the design of storage tank
Basic differences PCC RCC Plain Cement Concrete R/f Cement Concrete It doesn’t carry ‘Steel’. It carries Steel. PCC is weak in tension loading while strong in compression loading. RCC is strong in both. PCC blasts on excessive loading & in an instant w/t giving any warning. RCC gives you enoughRead more
Basic differences
PCC | RCC |
Plain Cement Concrete | R/f Cement Concrete |
It doesn’t carry ‘Steel’. | It carries Steel. |
PCC is weak in tension loading while strong in compression loading. | RCC is strong in both. |
PCC blasts on excessive loading & in an instant w/t giving any warning. | RCC gives you enough time to vacate the structure before collapse. |
Plain Cement Concrete | R/f Cement Concrete | |
Tension | Steel tendons
High tensile steel bars Included with tension |
Ordinary Mild Steel Deformed Bars
No tension included |
Basic materials used | Min grade of concrete
Post-Tensioning → M30 Pre-Tensioning → M40 to resist high stresses
High strength steel to transfer large prestressing force |
Min grade of concrete → M20
Steel → MS |
Effectiveness of member | Entire section carries load | Does not carries load |
Crack resistance | High
Cracks don’t occur under working loads |
Less |
Wt & suitability | Light
Heavy loads & longer spans |
Heavy
Wt is more desired than steel |
Equiments | Requires many specialized equiments
Pulling jack, Post-tensioning pump, Master wedges, Anchhor head & bearing |
Doesn’t involve specialized equiments. |
Quality of steel reqd | 1/3rd of RCC
More strength & less c/s area |
More |
Deflection | Very less | More |
Load carrying capacity & Durability | More | Less |
Shock resistance | More | Less |
Yield | As high as 2100 N/mm2 | 200 – 300 N/mm2 |
Testing | Testing of steel & concrete can be done while prestressing. | No way of testing the steel & concrete. |
Cost | Economical for span of 10m – 18m.
As length of span gets ↑ Cost % ↑ C/s area of beam ↓ |
Economical for span < 9m. |
aviratdhodare
First, you must determine WHAT you are going to store and HOW it will react to the material the tank is made from. i.e. a water storage tank just may be made from something different than concentrated sulfuric acid. Next, you need to take into consideration the quantity to be stored which will yieldRead more
First, you must determine WHAT you are going to store and HOW it will react to the material the tank is made from. i.e. a water storage tank just may be made from something different than concentrated sulfuric acid.
Next, you need to take into consideration the quantity to be stored which will yield the weight and the pressure forces put on the floor and the sides of the tank. This will tell you how strong the tank needs to be in thickness and reinforcement structures.
See less